Skip to main content

Capital Punishment Against Bali Bombers

Bali bombing memorial
Last night, when I watching TV, I be attracted with the news about capital punishment against the main performers of the Bali Bombings incident. According to "TV One" (one of the Indonesian TV broadcasting), on October 24, 2008 (means today), the Indonesian attorney general will announce the execution plan for them. Faced that announcement, their family will put forward the re-consideration through their lawyer team next week.

Yes, according to the law, they were guilty and must be punished. But the capital punishment is equivalent with splitting the soul from the body. My big question is "Whether these world must have the capital punishment?" I don't know!

Photo: The Bali bombing memorial on the site of Paddy's Pub.
Taken from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_Bali_bombings

Comments

  1. Hi sir, TV one often present the reportage about Bali blast since many days ago. And I saw when it shows the Bali bom occurence some days ago. It's really made my heart melt to see the victims...
    I agree that they must be get capital pumishment

    ReplyDelete
  2. segala cara kekerasan harus dihujat. Apalagi pake bom-boman. Siapapun pelakunya harus dihukum seberat2nya dengan alasan apapun..

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't think capital punishment achieves anything. They could be put in jail for life.

    Robin (Australia)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Like Robin, Tikno, I am opposed to capital punishment. So I do not want the Bali bombers executed. Many Australians hold different views to Robin and I. However, while I recognise all the arguments, I have been opposed for a very long time on moral grounds.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dear Niar,
    I think... we are NOT the owner of the human's soul. I agree with Robin, they could be put in jail for life -OR- until they want by themselves. Thanks for your vote (agree).
    -------------------

    Dear Blogendeng,
    Yes, any guilty people must be punished. But you not yet answered the big question explicitly, agree or not. Thank you for your comment
    -------------------

    Dear Robin,
    Yes, I agree with you.
    --------------------

    Dear Jim Belshaw,
    Yes, I agree with you. The most important is... we are not the owner of any soul.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I must disagree with the popular opinion here. If ever, the perpetrator gets free, he will kill again.

    ReplyDelete
  7. i remember the bali bombing. it was tragic. the news focused on the bombing as it damaged many lives.

    thank you for the update on this case. i think life sentence is still the best punishment.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Dear Rummuser,
    Like Robin said, they could be put in jail for life. I think it can prevent the perpetrator to kill again. It mean by replacing capital punishment with life sentence. I see Niar same with you to agree the capital punishment.
    ---------------------

    Dear The Dong,
    Your vote added the amount of those who not agree to capital punishment. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Islam not terorism, Islam love peace. Iam disagree bomb against western.....peace for all

    ReplyDelete
  10. wuih... bunda mudheng sedikit..yang jelas.. bunda mendukung hukuman seadil2nya.. (karena bagaimanapun mencabut nyawa adalah urusanNya)

    ReplyDelete
  11. Dear Mikekono,
    Yes, I agree with you too.
    -------------------

    Dear Bunda Rierie,
    Nice words.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I just belive that life and death is God's prerogrative...nobody has the right to kill others,
    warm regards

    ReplyDelete
  13. some people might say that capital punishment doesn't belong in civilized society, but despite this fact, i think we still need it as an instrument to deal with extremely dangerous criminals such as terrorists and murderers

    ReplyDelete
  14. sedikit ribet dan susah jika bilang harus ada "hukuman mati" karena seperti bunda ririe bilang urusan mencabut nyawa merupakan urusan-Nya. skg pertanyaan ely sangat erat dengan itu, kenapa manusia membuat hukum seperti itu padahal sudah jelas kalau hak seperti itu cuma Tuhan saja yg memiliki (dalam hal ini mencabut nyawa)??

    dan saya cuma bilang, kenapa agama dipakai untuk tameng dalam perbuatan itu?haruskah dengan jalan kekerasan seperti itu?apakah semua orang bersalah dan harus dihukum dgn jalan seperti itu?

    saya yakin agama islam tdk seperti itu, dan saya percaya semua agama itu baik dan mengajarkan hal yg baik pula, itu hanya ulah sebagian kecil orang2 yg salah arah dalam mempelajari agamanya.

    jika untuk urusan hukuman mati, saya saya lebih setuju dengan jawaban bunda ririe, jawaban yg bijaksana menurut saya.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Excellent commentary! I use to be very pro capital punishment; however, my Christian belief has changed my perspective. I agree; it is not up to us to decide the final punishment. It is up to God to judge the soul. I think our most important thought should be protecting society, not getting revenge. Therefore; jail without any chance of release and without any contact with the outside world or anyone else would be my “worldly” decision. Let them sit alone and think about what they have done until God takes them.

    Also, thank you for visiting my Blog and leaving a nice comment! Bless you and Take Care! If you are ever in the USA, you have a fiend in California.

    Scott McQueen
    www.scottmcqueen.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  16. Dear Tikno,

    I'm afraid I must disagree with you and most of your readers, on this issue.

    If there really was a GUARANTEE of life in prison with no chance of parole, perhaps I might feel differently, but too many "lifers" have been released back into society for me to believe there is safety in imprisonment. There are too many loopholes that allow evil people back into society to harm others.

    I am a professing Christian, and I do not believe that the soul is destroyed with the body. Whether death comes from accident, murder or old age, the soul survives.

    If Bali law says that murder is punishable by execution, then the bombers KNOWINGLY decided to kill others, knowing what fate COULD await them. Their victims did not have that same freedom of choice.

    To execute murderers under the law is NOT revenge, it is justice.

    Also, I feel no obligation to pay for supporting a murderer in prison for the rest of his/her natural life. Especially since so many manage to find freedom through escape or legal duplicity - only to continue killing.

    We have seen many, many cases of murder in the United States, that could have been prevented if the murderer had NOT been eventually set free.

    Old enough to have seen it happen,
    Brennan

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hello there! well the game is simple. You just needed to guess where I was. To see the question you should pass the mouse over the sentence, that was a trick. Have a look back there and realise there is indeed a question if you select the text with your mouse. =) See you back there soon :)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Bali was such a nice place and it was so sad that somebody ruined it.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Hi Grace. While I have been reading, I wasn't going to comment further in this discussion. However, I do want to pick up one point.

    I understand the feeling behind your comment and know what you mean, but it is I think important to recognise that the Bali bombers did not ruin Bali.

    There are close relations between Australia and Bali. This is one of our major holiday destinations. Australians really like the Balinese.

    Of the Australians killed, 20 came from Coogee, the Sydney suburb in which we used to live, some 8 from one local football team. There is a memorial in Coogee, there was another annual memorial ceremony recently.

    When the bombings occured, there was a sharp drop in tourism to Bali. The Australian Government issued an official warning against going. In response, some Australians moved their holidays forward to go to Bali, others actually changed holiday destinations to go there.

    Bali was a tragedy first for Indonesia, then Australia and for all those involved. But I think it important to recognise that Bali is still there, that it has not been ruined.

    Grace, please don't think that I am being critical. I understand the feeling behind your words. I just wanted to re-affirm Bali.

    In the midst of the sometimes dsitorted discussion about current terrorism issues, it is important to remember that terrorism is not new.

    I went to London a number of times at the height of the IRA bombing campaign on official business and as a tourist. Of course I knew that there was a risk - the British minstries I visited had bomb-blast curtains, I was conscious in the streets of some risk. However, it was important not to let this affect day to day asctivities.

    My apologies for a post that has become something of a sermon, but I do worry about the way that the activities of certain individuals affect the rest of us.

    Congratulations Tikno, by the way, on such a good comments stream.

    ReplyDelete
  20. A tough question. Although I am generally against capital punishment, I can see both sides of this issue.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Dear Tjonjo,
    Warm regards to you too.
    -------------------

    Dear Ernita,
    Thank you for your comment. Perhaps, comment from Scott Mcqueen could answered you. Thank you Scott Mcqueen.
    -------------------

    Dear Blogger Addicter,
    Wow... you support Bunda Rierie.
    ------------------

    Dear Scott Mcqueen,
    My opinion also same with you. Thank you for the warm welcome. I will contact you if I go to California.
    -------------------

    Dear Brennan Kingsland,
    No problem, I appreciate different opinion. Thank you for describe your answer and I still musing it. You always be my friend although we have different opinion.
    ------------------

    Dear Lorrie,
    I tried your game many times but can't find the answer. Thanks for coming.
    -----------------

    Dear Grace,
    Like Jim said, I agree with him.
    -----------------

    Dear Jim Belshaw,
    Thank you so much for the wise thought. I quote your sentence "it is important to remember that terrorism is not new". Excellent!
    I hesitant that the capital punishment will end terrorism, and believe, that is not the only way.
    -----------------

    Dear Petrea,
    You gave a very careful answer. Thank you for giving your vote: "generally against capital punishment"
    -----------------

    I appreciated all the differences of opinion here. Till at this time the issue of the "capital punishment" still being a debate, because of the different point of view. Partly saw from the angle of religion and partly from the angle of justice.

    Personally, I only want to distinguish the matters that became the human's right and the matters that became the God's right (our CREATOR).

    ReplyDelete
  22. According to me, the death penalty should exist. And I think, a long time to decide fate of the perpetrators of the Bali bombing, is enough to ensure that the government does not take any decision in.

    That is my opinion

    ReplyDelete
  23. Hi thank for your message.
    Keep writing and enjoy your life

    ReplyDelete
  24. Sounds a little wonder, why should the long jatuhi mukuman death. In the event has been long. It seems deliberately made slow ... maybe

    ReplyDelete
  25. Mas Tikno maaf komentar saya pakai bahasa indonesia yah..maklum bahasa Inggris saya kurang baik.
    Hanya satu opini saya dalam menyikapi masalah ini :
    Saya tidak melihat setuju atau tidak setuju, layak atau tidak layak, Bagaimanapun juga pada akhirnya sebuah kepantasan yang akan didapatkan oleh seseorang dari setiap perbuatannya.
    Barangkali inilah hukuman kepantasan yang dimaksud.

    ReplyDelete
  26. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Tikno, I have often wondered what I would do if I found myself on a jury and capital punishment was a possible sentence. I now know that I could not make the decision to take someone’s life. I do not believe that is a right that has been given to any of us. It is certainly not a deterrent to crime.

    On the other hand, I think if someone is sentenced to prison, they should work for their food and shelter. Body building does not count. There are many jobs that can be performed by prisoners and I think they should get up each morning and work on one.

    So, Tikno my answer is no to capital punishment-no matter what the crime.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Dear Anthony Harman,
    Thank you for the vote = agree
    ---------------------
    Dear Zhejiang Shuguang lamps Co,Ltd,
    Thank you for coming.
    ---------------------
    Dear Pangki Fernandes,
    I guess you also "agree". Welcome to you.
    ---------------------
    Dear Yopan Prihadi,
    An interesting answer from you. You see from an angle of "appropriateness". But, I think it's difficult for measuring, because it depending on each person's feelings. Anyway, this is another thought to be mused.
    ---------------------
    To whom comment was deleted,
    I beg you please not ridicule to the personal, although has been guilty. Please answer whether you "agree" or "not" with your own description. I'll be happy waiting it.
    ----------------------
    Dear Mckay K,
    Thank you for sharing your thoughts. You know that I proud of you, your strength to fight in life and your noble heart to share to everyone.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I sent my condolences to the bombing victim. I agree when people said that it's one of the biggest terrorism in the Indonesian history. It's not about Islam, but it's all about the people with their "unique" interpretation about Islam.

    @ the early of November, they will be executed. But I'm not sure it will be the final moment of terrorism. I believe that (may be) mostly people in the world curse these activities

    Salam.

    ^_^

    ReplyDelete
  30. Dear Fajar Indra,
    Yes, I think so. That's not the ending story. Thank you for your comment

    ReplyDelete
  31. Capital punishment makes no sense, and is foolish and cruel. For example: Why do they kill people to show that killing people is wrong?

    ReplyDelete
  32. Dear Static Brain,
    A thought-provoking question. Excellent !

    ReplyDelete
  33. All of these websites concerning the capital punishment have often been a controversial. The most outstanding doubt is whether capital punishment is a method for torturing or just a punishment for dangerous criminals.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Hi the Author of Viagra Online,
    Are you addressing the life sentence to torturing and the death sentence to punishment?
    Seems like you still doubt to choose.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

COMMENT POLICY : Spam comments or sounds like advertisement will be deleted without notice. Do not hesitate to write the dissent or critical comments.

Popular posts from this blog

VETO VS DEMOCRACY

In this post I only quotes the things associated with the two words above. Please use your sense and read carefully to find and feel the fundamental differences from it.

VETO
According to Wikipedia: "A veto, Latin for "I FORBID" is used to denote that a certain party has the right to stop unilaterally a certain piece of legislation. In practice, the veto can be ABSOLUTE (as in the U.N. Security Council, whose permanent members can block any resolution). In the United Nations Security Council, the five permanent members (the United States, Russia, the People's Republic of China, France and the United Kingdom) have veto power in substantive matters, though NOT in procedural ones. If any of these countries votes against a proposal, it is REJECTED, even if all of the other member countries vote in FAVOUR."

According to Global Policy Forum: "The five permanent members of the Security Council (China, France, Russia, United Kingdom, and United States) ENJOY the p…

Messages from golden wedding anniversary

The wedding anniversary was historically derived from Roman empire tradition, where husbands crown his wife with a silver wreath on their twenty-fifth anniversary, and a gold wreath on the fiftieth anniversary. In the present, generally, it called silver wedding anniversary for 25th years of marriage and the golden wedding anniversary for 50th years of marriage. Many people dream of their wedding will be lasting but many of them also fail.

For those of you who dream of it, then there is a philosophical message from a modest golden wedding anniversary, a pieces of dialog between emcee and bride, as follow :

Emcee : (jokingly) "What is the most annoying thing from your husband?"
Bride : "As many as the stars in the sky, unable to count them"
Emcee : (shocked) "Well, but your husband's kindness is also abundant, right?"
Bride : "A little, like the sun in the sky"
Emcee : (curious) "Then why you could live with him for half a century and st…

What a PhD mean for you

What is Ph.D.? Yes, I know it is an academic degree. That's it. No, I think. It's hard to describe it in words. You better focus on the illustration below:





And... the things that made me fall silent is what was said by Matt:
"If you zoom in on the boundary of human knowledge in the direction of genetics, there's something just outside humanity's reach. My wife and I chose to start funding these graduate students after we learned that our son has a rare, fatal genetic disorder. It may be too late for my son, but it's not too late for other children. Even one child suffering is one child too many. The only way to end this kind of suffering is science. And, the best way to do science is through graduate students."
What a beautifull thoughts that touched my heart.
Note: This work is originaly from The Illustrated Guide to a Ph.D. by Matt Might.

STOP the hatred war in the social networking site

Lately, I feel very worried by unscrupulous users of Facebook who already out of the spirit of Facebook motto namely "Facebook helps you connect and share with the people in your life". Some of Facebook users who use this site only for uploading pornographic images and shared it using private setting to certain people (not shared to everyone) and the other using it for spreading the hatred feelings, like a Facebook Group calling for Obama's death.

Although a very controversial Pages on Facebook namely "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" which it created by Seattle cartoonist Molly Norris has been closed by Facebook after receiving protests from various parties including protests from the Indonesian government, the most recent controversy is the two opposing group on Facebook who mocked each other namely: "Everybody Draw Mohammed day (Indonesian version)" and the other one is "Everybody Draw Jesus day (Indonesian version)". As I observed on its la…

Diversity is destiny

Competition between pair Basuki Tjahaja Purnama (known as Ahok) - Djarot Saiful Hidayat and Anis Baswedan - Sandiaga Uno in the Jakarta gubernatorial election has ended. Although the scale of this election is only for Jakarta, this political contestation has a wide influence in Indonesia and gained international attention.

I do not want to talk at length about the first paragraph in this post because I'm sure everyone in Indonesia already knows about the political tension behind it and how its influence to the national unity. I am only interested in conveying the philosophical message to you all in relation to that matter.

Diversity is destiny. So that's destiny if in Indonesia there are Chinese, Balinese, Javanese, Sundanese, Acehnese, Irian, etc. More globally there are white, yellow, black. We can not choose to be born as what tribe or nation. We can not choose to be born in a Muslim, Christian, or Buddhist family. We can not choose to be born in rich family. It is God'…

Mother and Child - An Essay

WHEN YOU WERE A KID
She feed you, but as her reply... you spewed out your food and dropped the plate.
She bathe and clean your body, but as her reply..., you always bedwetting.
She taught you how to walk, but as her reply... you run to and fro when she shout to call you.
She taught you A-B-C-1-2-3, but as her reply... you doodling the wall.
She bought beautiful clothes for your, but as her reply... you soiling her clothes.
She accompanied you went to kindergarten, but as her reply... you shouted NO.. NO..!
She paid your study, but as her reply... you often absent.
She forbid you to see the TV show for adult, but as her reply... you wait until she go out and quietly turn on the TV.

WHEN YOU WERE ADULT
She paid your party for sweet seventeen, but as her reply... you continued the party until daybreak.
She drive you to the school but... you felt shy when the car stop in front of school.
She asked when you came late at night, but as her reply... you said "Oh Mommy, I already adult n…