Skip to main content

Between two interests - oil and democracy

As we know the pro-democracy movement was on the rise in the Middle East and North Africa. The victim started from Ben Ali in Tunisia, Hosni Mubarak in Egypt, Yemen, and the next candidate is Muammar Gaddafi in Libya, and maybe Bahrain. I also saw a wave of pro-democracy has brought a sense of worry for countries in the Middle East including Saudi Arabia.

When pro-democracy movement shook Tunisia, oil prices has not been affected, likewise when these movement travel to Egypt, because these two countries was not a significant oil producer for the world. But when the pro-democracy protests spread to Libya, oil prices has jumped since mid-February when the rebellion in Libya increases.

Thus Saudi Arabia was forced to increase its oil production in order to maintain the stability of world energy and cooling the overheated energy prices. The most frightening is that if pro-democracy demonstrations spread to Saudi Arabia.

It seems that USA and European countries are aware that the longer the oil supply disrupted, it will bring economic chaos for them as the countries who depend on oil supply from non-democratic countries (Islamic and/or authoritarian countries) like Libya, Bahrain, Saudi Arabia and Middle East countries. Moreover, the U.S. economy was still giddy after the global crisis and European economy are not yet better.

Therefore I have an intriguing question. Which one you choose? If you choose oil, it means you better support the Islamic monarchy in the Middle East (of course with their unique value as well). Or... proactively support the pro-democracy movement in the Middle East.

Comments

  1. That is precisely the hobson's choice that the West is grappling with now Tikno. We are living in very interesting times don't you think?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Rummuser,
    I believe the spirit of democracy is not easily extinguished. It's easier to destroy a tank. On the other hand, I also believe that the attack from the inner side (from their own people) is something that is difficult to be handled.

    If western countries prefer oil, it would mean denying their own value, that is democracy, which it often be used as an argument to middle east countries.

    As you have said: "We are living in very interesting times". You are right.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's hard when you're caught in the middle..but I still beleive in democracy and freedom.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Gina,
    Yes hard enough to make choices.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am all for democracy in Middle East. And perhaps it’s an emergency call for other countries to go through a revolution too in another form, which is to reduce their dependency on fossil fuel and move to more environmentally friendly energy. If there has to be something to trigger it, so this could be it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. It.s about time we get rid of both those dictators and their autocratic regimes and out addiction to and dependence on oil. Being optimistic I guess this is a once in a lifetime opportunity. It may temporarily hit the economies, but then transition always is a painful process. We need it - the Arabs to get their fundamental rights ( if they are wise enough not to opt for theocracies) and all of us to change from non sustainable to sustainable energy.

    colson

    ReplyDelete
  7. Aprianti,
    I hope one day women are allowed to drive in Saudi Arabia :)
    And you make a good thinking, this is the right moment to trigger the advancement of technology for renewable energy.

    Colson,
    But this lifetime opportunity cannot wait for a long-term plan (changing from non-sustainable to sustainable energy). So, hurry up! :(

    ReplyDelete
  8. @ tikno: Without the urgency of an exploding price of oil, nobody will hurry. But if China and the West will be cut off from the oil wells in the Arab countries, the urgency to change to other sources will be huge. That's probably the only way to overrule the company interests of BP, Shell etc and bring real change about.

    ReplyDelete
  9. @ Colson,
    Maybe it's the best moment, a lifetime opportunity, to trigger revival in both democracy and sustainable energy.

    Actually, I would love to see that sustainable energy will dominate this world for the sake of our next generation. When that happens then this would be a bad signal for middle east countries who being rich because of fossil oil.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi Tikno,
    I think the EU, USA, Japan and others would be very careful with Saudi Arabia. They have a very bad experience with Iran which used to be very good friend when it was under Shah Iran and became enemy after Khomeini came to power. There is no guarantee that similar tyrant would not emerge. Especially that in Tunis and Egypt the fanatics are estimated to have lead the revolutions.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Multibrand,
    I still believe that the spirit of democracy and demands for gender equality is not easily extinguished in their hearts, even if the new tyranny emerge again. Please look at this news (about women want to drive in Saudi Arabia):

    http://content.usatoday.com/communities/ondeadline/post/2011/03/senior-saudi-prince-suggests-lifting-ban-on-women-driving/1

    The key is their citizenry still lulled by oil wealth. Situation will be different if renewable energy can be dominant and replace fossil oil.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Anonymous29/3/11

    Tikno, sorry I'm late to the conversation! I do not think the U.S. (at least) has much of a choice. When people take to the streets and demand democracy, the U.S. simply has to support them. That should not always be with military force, but at least with encouragement, maybe humanitarian aid, and the like.

    The U.S. must stand for democracy. What else can we do?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Anonymous29/3/11

    Hi Consultus - in fact your country already use military force such as missile rain... yeah that's a must - right?

    ReplyDelete
  14. @ CONSVLTVS,
    But... well... it seems that for the case of Libya now, the world was a bit understand that "you are invited". This is not the same as in Iraq (considered uninvited). Perhaps Obama's approach is better than its predecessor, or maybe he have a bit of Indonesia's value when childhood ;)

    btw, allow me shoot your heart using this missile

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

NOTE: comment moderation is activated due to a lot of spam comments. Comments containing racial hatred, personal attacks, or advertising are strictly prohibited.

POPULAR POSTS LAST 7 DAYS:

Chinese New Year 2560 - Gong Xi Fa Cai

On January 26th 2009 (Indonesian time) the Chinese people around the world celebrate the Chinese New Year 2560th (old enough I think). It's sometimes called the Lunar New Year . Following tradition, at the night one day before the first day of new year, all family members gather together for dinner. The chosen venue usually at the home of the most senior member of the family or at restaurant. After dinner, usually followed by giving the red envelopes ( Hongbao in Mandarin; Angpao in Indonesian) from married couples or the elderly to unmarried juniors, and the junior member give respect by saying the hope for health, happiness, and long-aged to the elderly. Prayer at the temples and visiting the other elderly relatives is the next schedules. In Indonesia, I noted that since the era of President Abdurrahman Wahid (also known as Gus Dur), the Chinese culture such as lion dance (Indonesian called Barongsai), the use of Chinese characters and Chinese red paper lantern for decor

Christmas Contemplation When The Bell Ringing

A few days ago, I visited a mall to buy something. The atmosphere was very rousing with Christmas decorations and I believe also occurs around the world. Producers take advantage of Christmas moment to compete and increase sales with tempting offers, such as: discount 20%, 30%, 40%, buy one get one, etc. Parents are busy thinking of what gifts should be purchased, and children imagining of what the gift they will get. Many people calculate their money for the best holiday package. That's NOT wrong! But... when the bell is ringing.... Before: Christmas is the birth of Savior! Now: Santa, where is my gift? Before: That is the beginning of the redemption of our sin. Now: Let's be happy for welcoming Christmas and new year. Before: Jesus has come in simplicity. Now: Let's go holiday ! I'm just imagining the genuine spirit of why we celebrate Christmas has gone. And... in this opportunity, I want to tell you that the Christmas bell resounding the call to the soul to follow t

Flood In Samarinda City

From Friday, November 7th 2008 (Indonesian time), the flood was happened at several places in Samarinda city, and four days next (November 11th) has overflowed into more areas. Close to afternoon the electricity around the city has switched off by the electric company. At one place, a student Roby has died because the flood's water containing electric current derived from the traffic light pole. That's the reason why the electricity cannot be switched on until they find its problems. Local newspapers had reported that in several places the flood's height is about 40 to 100 cm and flooding over hundreds houses. Schools and shops in serious flood location has been holiday. From obtained news, the flood was caused by the high rainfall, dam water overflow, the river water was rising and was aggravated with the shallow riverbed. In the area of the Unmul botanical garden, as many as thirteen crocodile was wandering because the guardrail was broken as a result of being bashed by t