Skip to main content

Someone has stolen my article - plagiarism

A user of www.Zimbio.com with the initials "Pinoy" has stolen my articles titled "Long journey for alcoholic beverage in Indonesia" without my permission nor mentioning the source of original post (my article). I call this plagiarism or cheating. He/She has completely copying (stole) my article into his/her blog and then submit that article to www.Zimbio.com using his/her blog as the source with user name "Pinoy".

Firstly I found my article was published at www.Zimbio.com with the URL:
http://www.zimbio.com/member/pinoy/articles/Lz8BZTf7gh9/%20Long+journey+alcoholic+beverage+Indonesia

And below is the captured image from Zimbio page, where my article has been stolen by Pinoy. Click the image to enlarge and look at the red arrow or visit its link to dig more.

You can see that the source of article was written from "global-ids.blogspot.com" (plagiarist blog). Out of curiosity then I clicked on the link and found my article are also stolen and copied into his / her blog, with the URL = http://global-ids.blogspot.com/2010/06/long-journey-for-alcoholic-beverage-in.html





Below is the image captured from plagiarist blog:

Wooow... the plagiarist was stole my article to makes money online via Google Adsense, ha... ha...
Maybe I would not mind if only quoting part of paragraph (not 100%) and write the original source.
Some people still think that what has been published on the Internet is public property because the Internet is a public space. Is this true? And what should I do for this case? Any suggestions?










This is a good example shown by Social Computing Software website. Their website Admin provides a link to the original source. I give a great respect to the Admin.








 = Update on July 27, 2010 for a good news =
Yesterday morning, July 26, 2010, I sent my report to Zimbio as suggested by Yenni in comment to this post. And today, July 27, 2010 afternoon, I get a reply from Zimbio to informed me that they have reviewed this matter and the article was removed (click on the image of their email to enlarge). A good news and also a rapid reply that makes my salute to them. Ohh ... my efforts were not in vain. Now just waiting for a reaction from Google on my report about his plagiarism post which it using blogger as a platform. Let appreciate other people's work and do not keep silent against plagiarism.

Comments

  1. stupid plagiarist.. maybe you can comment to the article or spam him to apologize..

    ReplyDelete
  2. Looks like a marketing type gone crazy. Sometimes a computer is set up to copy articles and post automatically, and this done for a large number of sites. You may not be able to contact the true perpetrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Meutia,
    I think he/she is a naughty blogger but clever to makes money online. Right now, I choose to report his/her copy-paste post to Google via "Google's spam report form":
    http://www.google.com/contact/spamreport.html

    Looney,
    Ah... that's good so this post also can be read automaticaly by their blog readers and probably by the perpetrator. Just say am sending a message for them via this post, ha... ha....

    ReplyDelete
  4. I always provide a link and credits if I paste an article on my blog an d also ask for permission first, even for a photo.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Though you definitely caught the plagiarist in a flagrant act of foul play, I've no idea what to do about it effectively. Like you said: internet is ( and ought to stay in my opinion) free.

    At least he/she gave you a huge compliment: she/he thinks your article is better than what he/she may ever be able to write on the subject.

    ReplyDelete
  6. first of all I should congratulate you for such a good article you have, and may be this Pinoy also feel the same way.
    2ndly, let's see what will google do after your report on http://www.google.com/contact/spamreport.html . Let us know the update on this case.

    ReplyDelete
  7. tikno, write to copyright@zimbio.com for this plagiarism issue. it's just very rude of her!

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Amrita,
    That's good for you. I respect you!

    Colson,
    Yup, internet is free for everyone to read, for personal use and non-profits, but not for copyright piracy especially for particular interests.
    I felt that was plagiarism not a huge compliment.

    Prihandoko,
    I will add an update in this post or in new post if I see what Google do after receiving my report.
    Would you please to help me by sending a report too?

    Yeni,
    I will try it. Thanks for your attention.
    Perhaps they will more care about this case if you also makes a report to them. Will you help me?

    Nikiti Migina,
    I'm sorry to delete your comment. Please do not write your advertisement here.

    ReplyDelete
  10. jangan niru deh mending buat karya sendiri

    ReplyDelete
  11. I also have become victims of plagiarism. Setuju! Stop copy-paste!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Julianusginting,
    Setuju !

    Sawali Tuhusetya,
    If so, don't keep silent.

    ReplyDelete
  13. tidak mudah untuk mencari ide menulis, jadi berbanggalah dengan karya sendiri.. :)
    terimakasih

    ReplyDelete
  14. sunggu tidak enak dikopas
    apalagi tidak menyebut sumbernya
    kopas dengan menyebutkan sumber sih oke aja

    ReplyDelete
  15. Sukadi,
    Kalau dikopas jadi sedih nih..

    Attaya,
    Walaupun menyebut sumber asli tapi bukan berarti boleh copy 100%

    ReplyDelete
  16. I have been victims plagiarist. I sent email for her and i complain for her behaviour. The last, she ask for pardon to me....

    ReplyDelete
  17. Meliana,
    You have done what should be done to fight plagiarism. I'm stand with you. :)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hi Tikno,

    Good job. I'm glad you fought plagiarism and got good results.

    I think if you want your readers to see an article you shouldn't copy it but link to it. Google loves links, and when you use them you raise your site and the other person's site in Google's page rankings. Copying the article does nothing for you or for the other person, even if you give credit to the other person.

    If you use links, you're not plagiarizing, and everybody's happy.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Hi Petrea,
    Welcome back and thanks for your comment.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Plagiarism is a form of flattery Tikno! Congratulations for having been copied and also so effectively resolving the issue.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Rummuser,
    You said flattery? I don't even think like that. I was peeved with what has happened.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Good for you for speaking up! I try to be very careful about giving credit for anything I refer to. I also notice a lot of people use other people's pictures without getting permission or giving credit. I stick to pictures that have a Creative Commons license or else write for permission.

    About being flattered. Having someone refer to your post and giving you credit would have been flattery. Stealing is not!

    ReplyDelete
  23. Hello Tikno how have you been?? Been a while since I have stopped here, Hope your doing well and your family is doing well... You all have a wonderful weekend...

    ReplyDelete
  24. Cheerful Monk,
    Yeah I feel good after speaking and got a good news, moreover after got email reply from you :)

    JK,
    I'm fine. Just doing my daily job even for weekend. My job does not give me an opportunity for weekend :(

    ReplyDelete
  25. Dear Tikno,
    It's really a shame that people would take advantage of such a nice person. I'm glad that:
    1) You discovered the plagiarism, whether it was intentional or not,
    2) Took action to resolve it.

    As an author, I often have my words quoted back to me - which is really a complement - but I have never bothered to check whether people are stealing my stuff or not.

    As for your case, if this was one of those automatic posting softwares, I understood that they always include the credits for the author. If they don't, they should be made illegal.
    Worth checking out, huh?

    I'm glad you followed up and got good results. You deserve it.

    Your friend,
    Brennan

    ReplyDelete
  26. Dear Brennan,

    Actually I accidentally found my article was plagiarized when I just testing a plagiarism checker at http://www.copyscape.com

    I heard that plagiarism also happened on educational world where student wrote a papers by copying from internet sources.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Tikno: Your new motto (Love Elly & Alex) moves me! Beautiful!

    ReplyDelete
  28. Salam kenal Mas, pertanyaan anda sudah saya jawab sebisa saya.. mohon petunjuknya...

    ReplyDelete
  29. Colson,
    Thank you. That's my own handwriting.

    Indonesiarek,
    Salam kenal juga. Saya sudah membacanya dan terimakasih sudah dijawab.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and have my children check up here often. I am quite sure they will learn lots of new stuff here than anybody else!

    ReplyDelete
  31. @ News,
    As an author, I'm so excited if my writings were considered valuable. It's push my spirit to write better. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  32. I'm VERY glad you took care of this and the article was removed. Have you written a letter of protest to the plagiarist?

    Sorry you had to experience this, but I guess it was a good lesson for all of us...BEWARE the greedy folks who steal art and writing!

    ReplyDelete
  33. @ Lynda Lehmann,
    Yes, first I asked the perpetrator to remove my article on his/her blog by writing a comment. Because there is no response, then I published this post and write a protest email to Zimbio and Google.
    Beware to your art works. Since you published it on the internet, there is always a risk.

    ReplyDelete
  34. That is so scary Tikno----That's why I registered my site with Creative Commons and MyCopyrights --to protect my site.
    I have read about other blogger's writings being plagiarized by others. There are so many of them ---those cheaters.
    You did a good job reporting it to Zimbio and Google.

    ReplyDelete
  35. waduh ko bahasanya bule..ane jadi bingung salam kenal kawan..jalan2 disiang hari menawarkan produk kami..kami adalah supplier spare part komputer..di jamin murah banget..di lihat ya kawan

    ReplyDelete
  36. ada ga versi indonesianay bro..kayanya menarik nih artikel..banyak yang komentar

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

COMMENT POLICY : Spam comments will be deleted without notice.

Popular posts from this blog

Mr. Money is not guilty

This is a special guest post. The grievances and notice from Mr. Money that share it in sorrow to readers. Please read carefully below :

My name is Mr. Money (sometime was called : Dough). My face is just plain, my physical is also weak, but I am able to overhaul the world order.

I'm able to change the behavior even human nature because humans idolize me. Many people change their personality, betray friends, sell their bodies, even abandon their faith, for my sake. That's not my command, note that!

I really do not understand the difference of pious and depraved people, but humans using me as a benchmark, determine rich or poor, honorable or lowly. Blame to human, not me.

I am not devil, but often people do abominations because of me. So I ask for justice who is the real devil.

I'm not the third person to make them divorced or make children and parents quarrel. I beg to the judge to re-examine this case.

It is very clear that I am not God. You must obey your religion forbid…

VETO VS DEMOCRACY

In this post I only quotes the things associated with the two words above. Please use your sense and read carefully to find and feel the fundamental differences from it.

VETO
According to Wikipedia: "A veto, Latin for "I FORBID" is used to denote that a certain party has the right to stop unilaterally a certain piece of legislation. In practice, the veto can be ABSOLUTE (as in the U.N. Security Council, whose permanent members can block any resolution). In the United Nations Security Council, the five permanent members (the United States, Russia, the People's Republic of China, France and the United Kingdom) have veto power in substantive matters, though NOT in procedural ones. If any of these countries votes against a proposal, it is REJECTED, even if all of the other member countries vote in FAVOUR."

According to Global Policy Forum: "The five permanent members of the Security Council (China, France, Russia, United Kingdom, and United States) ENJOY the p…

Messages from golden wedding anniversary

The wedding anniversary was historically derived from Roman empire tradition, where husbands crown his wife with a silver wreath on their twenty-fifth anniversary, and a gold wreath on the fiftieth anniversary. In the present, generally, it called silver wedding anniversary for 25th years of marriage and the golden wedding anniversary for 50th years of marriage. Many people dream of their wedding will be lasting but many of them also fail.

For those of you who dream of it, then there is a philosophical message from a modest golden wedding anniversary, a pieces of dialog between emcee and bride, as follow :

Emcee : (jokingly) "What is the most annoying thing from your husband?"
Bride : "As many as the stars in the sky, unable to count them"
Emcee : (shocked) "Well, but your husband's kindness is also abundant, right?"
Bride : "A little, like the sun in the sky"
Emcee : (curious) "Then why you could live with him for half a century and st…

What a PhD mean for you

What is Ph.D.? Yes, I know it is an academic degree. That's it. No, I think. It's hard to describe it in words. You better focus on the illustration below:





And... the things that made me fall silent is what was said by Matt:
"If you zoom in on the boundary of human knowledge in the direction of genetics, there's something just outside humanity's reach. My wife and I chose to start funding these graduate students after we learned that our son has a rare, fatal genetic disorder. It may be too late for my son, but it's not too late for other children. Even one child suffering is one child too many. The only way to end this kind of suffering is science. And, the best way to do science is through graduate students."
What a beautifull thoughts that touched my heart.
Note: This work is originaly from The Illustrated Guide to a Ph.D. by Matt Might.

STOP the hatred war in the social networking site

Lately, I feel very worried by unscrupulous users of Facebook who already out of the spirit of Facebook motto namely "Facebook helps you connect and share with the people in your life". Some of Facebook users who use this site only for uploading pornographic images and shared it using private setting to certain people (not shared to everyone) and the other using it for spreading the hatred feelings, like a Facebook Group calling for Obama's death.

Although a very controversial Pages on Facebook namely "Everybody Draw Mohammed Day" which it created by Seattle cartoonist Molly Norris has been closed by Facebook after receiving protests from various parties including protests from the Indonesian government, the most recent controversy is the two opposing group on Facebook who mocked each other namely: "Everybody Draw Mohammed day (Indonesian version)" and the other one is "Everybody Draw Jesus day (Indonesian version)". As I observed on its la…

Diversity is destiny

Competition between pair Basuki Tjahaja Purnama (known as Ahok) - Djarot Saiful Hidayat and Anis Baswedan - Sandiaga Uno in the Jakarta gubernatorial election has ended. Although the scale of this election is only for Jakarta, this political contestation has a wide influence in Indonesia and gained international attention.

I do not want to talk at length about the first paragraph in this post because I'm sure everyone in Indonesia already knows about the political tension behind it and how its influence to the national unity. I am only interested in conveying the philosophical message to you all in relation to that matter.

Diversity is destiny. So that's destiny if in Indonesia there are Chinese, Balinese, Javanese, Sundanese, Acehnese, Irian, etc. More globally there are white, yellow, black. We can not choose to be born as what tribe or nation. We can not choose to be born in a Muslim, Christian, or Buddhist family. We can not choose to be born in rich family. It is God'…

Capital Punishment Against Bali Bombers

Last night, when I watching TV, I be attracted with the news about capital punishment against the main performers of the Bali Bombings incident. According to "TV One" (one of the Indonesian TV broadcasting), on October 24, 2008 (means today), the Indonesian attorney general will announce the execution plan for them. Faced that announcement, their family will put forward the re-consideration through their lawyer team next week.

Yes, according to the law, they were guilty and must be punished. But the capital punishment is equivalent with splitting the soul from the body. My big question is "Whether these world must have the capital punishment?" I don't know!

Photo: The Bali bombing memorial on the site of Paddy's Pub.
Taken from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_Bali_bombings