Skip to main content

Fair by Logic or Feeling: A Test of Wisdom

The definition of "fair" according to the Cambridge Dictionary: treating someone in a way that is right or reasonable, or treating a group of people equally and not allowing personal opinions to influence your judgment. Well, that's the ideal. But can idealism always be implemented into practice effectively? The answer is not necessarily yes.

A few days ago, I was chatting casually at a coffee shop with friends. One of my friends told a story about parents who divided their wealth between their two sons. Both sons had their own families, but their financial conditions were very different. The first son was quite wealthy, while the second son was relatively poor. Their parents gave the larger share to the second son. This made the first son feel he was being treated unfairly. He felt his parents favored his younger brother.

This story steered our casual conversation toward the topic of fairness. There were two opinions. First, their parents should divide it equally to be fair. Second, their parents have a sense of fairness based on empathy. This second opinion was caught my attention to write this post because it is in the gray zone between black and white. I think the first opinion could be called "fair by logic" and the second opinion "fair by feeling" (but I prefer to call it "fair by wisdom"). So, what do you think about this matter? Is it fair for the poorer child to receive a larger share of the inheritance?

Justice

Of the two opinions above, I think the legal field faces the most challenging challenge. Judges must be adept at balancing legal provisions with society's sense of justice. For example: the law states that stealing someone else's property is punishable by five years in prison. Should a thief who steals a loaf of bread receive the same sentence as a car thief? Do you often hear that access to justice is often more difficult for the poor than for the wealthy who can afford expensive lawyers?

Being fair does not always mean giving the exact same thing to everyone (logical fairness), but rather ensuring that everyone gets what they need to succeed (empathetic fairness). Our greatest challenge is knowing when to stand firm on rigid rules, and when to act with empathy to embrace the diversity of human condition. In short: being human, not robot.

In closing, I have a most intriguing question: Does the veto power at the UN hurt the sense of justice for the majority of countries in the world?

Photo by dp singh Bhullar from Pexels with free use license.

Comments

  1. My own family's financial way above our living expense. So I don't mind my parents giving more of their inheritance to my sister because her life was hard and I love her.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. May I call it wisdom by love? Your sister is lucky to have you. I wish I were your brother too LOL

      Delete
  2. Adil, memang punya dua makna ya. Tergantung dari sudut mana memandangnya. Tapi Adil bijaksana, itu lebih penting.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Apakah adil bijaksana jika anak yang lebih miskin menerima warisan yang lebih besar.

      Delete
    2. what language is this, it reads so much like konkani.

      Delete
    3. Hi Parwatisingari, this is Indonesian language.

      Delete
  3. Fair may not seem fair to everyone unless you have some common sense.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fair by common sense? I'm still imagining it.

      Delete
  4. bagi je harta tu dgn adil 50-50 kpd kedua2nya mengikut faraid. Itu yg sepatutnya. X kisah la anak tu kaya atau miskin..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Salam Abam Kie, anda merujuk kepada hukum Islam "faraid". Setahu saya, hukum ini hanya digunakan selepas pemilik harta meninggal dunia.
      Nah... dalam kes ini, ibu-bapa mereka masih hidup. Bolehkah ibu-bapa memutuskan sendiri apa yang mereka rasa terbaik?

      Delete
    2. bisa diatur pak...

      Delete

Post a Comment

NOTE: Comments are moderated to block spam. Genuine comments will be published even if you are critical or disagree with me. Hate speech, personal attacks, ads, or spam will be removed.

POPULAR POSTS LAST 7 DAYS:

Chinese New Year 2560 - Gong Xi Fa Cai

On January 26th 2009 (Indonesian time) the Chinese people around the world celebrate the Chinese New Year 2560th (old enough I think). It's sometimes called the Lunar New Year . Following tradition, at the night one day before the first day of new year, all family members gather together for dinner. The chosen venue usually at the home of the most senior member of the family or at restaurant. After dinner, usually followed by giving the red envelopes ( Hongbao in Mandarin; Angpao in Indonesian) from married couples or the elderly to unmarried juniors, and the junior member give respect by saying the hope for health, happiness, and long-aged to the elderly. Prayer at the temples and visiting the other elderly relatives is the next schedules. In Indonesia, I noted that since the era of President Abdurrahman Wahid (also known as Gus Dur), the Chinese culture such as lion dance (Indonesian called Barongsai), the use of Chinese characters and Chinese red paper lantern for decor...

Five things I am proud of

I am typing this post while accompanying my baby sleeping at night. Jim Belshaw from Personal Reflections site, as I read on his short profile is a manager, strategic consultant, freelance researcher and social commentator, has asked me to write about 5 things I am proud of. And below is my duty for Jim. Become a father . I do not have a child during the first three-year marriage. Problem? maybe not in western but few bother here. In a relax chat people often ask : "How many children do you have?". While joking, my best friend ever said: "You're not yet being a real father until you have a child". Hmm... an uncomfortable question. But now I have Ely and Alex. Maybe Jim or readers will be laughing at me for this one, ha... ha... Not an unemployment . Really I will feel low-self if it happened. Harmonious with my siblings . Care each other when in trouble. Of course I need harmony with other people but with own siblings is the fundamental thing. My parents live w...

In Memory, my beloved brother

Actually, I do not think to make this post. But at one night, suddenly I look at his photo and remembered all his kindness and beautiful memories when he was still with us. Since December 23th, 2007, my beloved brother Rudiansyah Guyana has left us forever. He was a kind-hearted man, helpful to others, a man who love his family, an independent person, hard worker, and always want to go forward to reach for his dreams in order to be success in life and marry using his own money. I still remember when I was in hard conditions, he always gave genuine support. I never forget when I get married... he by sincerely gave some money to me by saying "For anything". Although a very little amount, but in sincerity I felt touched, moreover I knew he got it with very hard. And now... despite I'm a manager who have sizable income, I have no way to reply his kindness because he already went to the other world, forever. Feels like facing the door that was closed for me. For my lifetime I...